When can a lawyer defer providing information to a client?

A lawyer can defer providing information to a client in circumstances where it is believed that this delay may protect the client's interests. This involves a nuanced understanding of the client-lawyer relationship that prioritizes the client's well-being and strategic interests.

In situations where clients may react negatively, particularly to potentially damaging or sensitive information, a lawyer might choose to delay the communication. This approach can allow the lawyer to prepare the client for the ramifications of that information or to provide guidance that may help the client consider their options more thoughtfully.

The other choices do not align with the ethical responsibilities of a lawyer as effectively. If a client specifically requests a delay, while a lawyer might consider the request, it doesn't inherently provide justification for withholding important information. Similarly, needing more time to gather information is not a sufficient basis to defer communication without an understanding of how that deferment could affect the client's decision-making process. Therefore, option C stands out as being primarily focused on protecting the client's best interests through careful management of information.